This is a rustic place with a beautiful view of the Caribbean on the east side of Cozumel. We love the pottery cups our margaritas were served in. We enjoyed a house margarita made with Don Julio Silver, and we gave it a rating of 3.5 margarita glasses. Our favorite at Mezcalito’s was the second margarita made with Don Julio Reposado, which was fresh and strong. We give it 4.5 margarita glasses and could see this as a contender for the best margarita on the island.